Main RSS Feed Forum RSS Feed

Search

Next Fixture

No Upcoming Fixtures Available

Latest Poll

Should Edinburgh Rugby move to Easter Road on a permanent basis?



View Results

Log In






Forgot Password

Latest News

EDINBURGH SECOND BEST IN SWANSEA

Neathswansea Ospreys: 31 (24) Edinburgh Rugby: 22 (15)



You'd think that a match producing seven tries would be a bit of a thriller.  In fact, this evening's Guinness PRO12 encounter at the Liberty Stadium was a bit of a damp squib in the end.  In front of a sparse home crowd, the Ospreys never really hit the heights, but nonetheless managed to take a grip of this match after recovering from Will Helu's early try.  

The Welsh side had the bonus wrapped up early in the second period and never really looked threatened from then on in.  While possession and territory had been pretty even in the first period, the second saw Ospreys dominate both.  Edinburgh's discipline let them down badly.  They coughed up 13 penalties and two second half cards in close succession, leaving them chasing the game in the fourth quarter short handed.

Both Edinburgh cards were deserved. One felt, though, that both Beck and Smith were fortunate to have escaped a card themselves earlier on in the second period, having tipped The King Blairhorn beyond vertical and dropped him to the floor in a double tackle that went wrong.  Applying the letter of the law would have seen one of them in teh bin.  Meanwhile, local observers were not exactly wild when The King scored Edinburgh's second try after Hoyland had run into Evans as the latter was looking to field a high ball.  Whatever the rights and wrongs may have been, one felt that a bit less waving of arms by the men in black and a bit more graft in tracking back might have been a more productive response.

There was a fair bit of niggle up front, but rugby is a confrontational sport and that's part of the game.  One Man Wrecking Ball Jamie Ritchie is no respecter of reputations and he certainly let the illustrious Tipuric know he was there all night.  He wasn't averse to having a go at the legendary Alan Wyn Jones either.  This is one young pup who does not take a backward step.

Yet it was in attack that Ritchie's first notable contribution came.  After the impressive Davies had knocked over a penalty, Toolis blocked the young five eighth's clearance attempt, the ball was moved left and Blairhorn committed two tacklers with a step inside and a perfectly weighted pass to Ritchie.  The openside committed three defenders and put the supporting Helu cantering along the wing for a good try on eight minutes.  5-3 Edinburgh, but the lead was not to last long.

Tipuric knocked ball off the back of an Osprey lineout to Kiwi half back Leonard, who gave to Davies.  A fantastic line of running saw Howells clean through to canter over from the 22.  You should not concede off first phase, but it was a beautifully worked score nonetheless.  While Manu looked to have been taken out by a blocking runner, referee Phillips adjudged the pick to be legal and the home side were 10-5 up on 13 minutes.

A feature of the evening, at least until the statutory late flurry of replacements, was the Ospreys' domination of scrummage.   Both Dell and McCallum were under severe pressure most of the evening and a massive Osprey shove off an attacking scrummage saw Baker score on 18 minutes.

Blairhorn narrowed the gap on 27 minutes with his try after Hoyland and Evans had collided, The King cruising over from some distance. But Ospreys scored their third shortly afterwards, Tongan import Fia smashing over from short range to leave the score at the break 24-15 with Weir's penaty goal on the stroke of half-time.

Edinburgh were still in it, but another home try would start to take this one away from them.  And it duly came on 45 minutes, the latest Welsh wunderkind Keelan Giles scoring a cracker in the corner, Man of the Match AWJ the provider with fantastic hands for a little guy, let along a second row.  When Gilchrist was carded on 54 minutes for the latest in a series of Edinburgh offences, having been warned by the referee, it felt like the game was up.

While the Gunners managed to hold out during the power play without conceding any points, Dell was carded for a scrum offence on 68 minutes and there was definitely no way back.  Bill Mata did score the visitors' third from short range on 78 minutes and there was still time left to engineer a penalty or drop attempt for the losing bonus.  But the Embramen lost the ball in contact and left with nothing.

Another disappointment, then, and for all the prestidigitations of the Brylcreme boys in the Ospreys' back division - and there was plenty of good stuff - it was the home pack who dominated this match and delviered a well-deserved vistory.  A corollary of that is that the Gunners' pack did not impose themselves in tight or loose and can have fe complaints about the loss.

I'm beginning to think that it might be better for the Embramen now to focus on the Challenge Cup instead of the PRO12 as their potential route to Champions Cup rugby next season.

GUNNERS OUTSMARTED AT RODNEY PARADE

Newportgwentdragons: 27 (24) Edinburgh Rugby: 19 (12)

Time was when the Embramen would travel to Rodney Parade, get roundly bullied up front and return to the capital defeated men.  This outing was different, I suppose, in that it was the home side's brain rather than their brawn that proved to be the Gunners' undoing.  But it was still a loss, as the Dragons leapfrogged Edinburgh in the league.  The Embramen now sit a lowly tenth in the Guiness PRO12 with hopes of a top six finish this season beginning to look somewhat forlorn unless they can develop a bit of consistency.

The highlight - from a Newporter's point of view anyway - must have been the Dragons' first try, notched by South African import Carl Meyer, after veteran hooker Rhys Thomas had cheekily - and perfectly legally - pilfered ball from the back of a rapidly advancing Edinburgh maul to spark the counter.  The breakdown was a bit of a mess all afternoon, but young openside Ollie Griffiths was the deserved Man of the Match after dominating the tackle

Read More About GUNNERS OUTSMARTED

AN ARTIST'S REPLY TO JUST CRITICISM

Edinburgh Rugby: 28 (21) Ulster: 17 (3)

Dmitri Shostakovich had a complex relationship with Josef Stalin.  His masterpiece, the Fifth Symphony, was composed to rescue his career, and possibly his continued existence, after displeasing Stalin and the Soviet hierarchy generally with what they thought was a bit of a ropey opera work.  The Fifth did the trick, perhaps in part because he entitled it 'A Soviet Artist's Reply To Just Criticism'.

No doubt many among the Embra tifosi had exactly this parallel in mind before last night's match against Ulster kicked off at BT Murrayfield.  'Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk' was a barnstorming triumph by comparison with last week's embarrassing home loss against Zebre.

It's fair to say that the Embramen made amends with a comfortable 28-17 victory over the high flying province. They responded to the Zebre reverse in exactly the right way, sorting what needed sorting and playing with ambition, particularly in an excellent first period.  And it was the 21-3 half

Read More About AN ARTIST'S